Partial Similarity: How Do We Represent Uncertainty and Incompatibility?
How do people represent partial information when making decisions? We distinguish between two types of partial information: unknown features, whose values are hidden from the decision maker, and incompatible features, which are known to be absent rather than merely mismatched. We use similarity judgments to investigate how these two types of partial information are represented and to identify constraints on formal models of similarity. We designed an experiment using amoeba-like stimuli with three features located on their arms. To manipulate uncertainty, we obscured features by covering them with dirt. To manipulate incompatibility, we removed features entirely, resulting in two-dimensional amoebas. Using a comprehensive set of pairwise similarity judgments, we find four key results: (i) similarity decreases as the number of mismatching feature pairs increases; (ii) unknown features yield intermediate similarity judgments between known matches and known mismatches; (iii) stimuli with unknown features are not judged to be perfectly similar to themselves, challenging similarity models that represent uncertainty using a single point in feature space and compute similarity solely from distances between points; and (iv) incompatible features produce greater dissimilarity than known feature mismatches, suggesting that incompatibility is represented differently from certain mismatch and uncertainty. Together, these findings provide empirical constraints on formal theories of similarity under partial information. In particular, they motivate representations that capture uncertainty over feature values while distinguishing incompatibility from ordinary feature differences. Beyond static similarity judgments, such representations may also provide a foundation for dynamic models of decision making, in which individuals sequentially sample information to resolve uncertainty.
Keywords
There is nothing here yet. Be the first to create a thread.
Cite this as: